Minimap with link to location map
Filters
Price
Rating
Distance from Center
Rating (according to Stars)
Facilities

Check availability






Accommodations in Fire Island Pines You’ll Love

Affordable, Top-Rated Places to Stay in Fire Island Pines – For Every Budget

Looking for accommodation in Fire Island Pines (Florida)? Discover a wide range of places to stay starting at just $34.28 per night – from hotels and bed & breakfasts to vacation rentals. Whether you're visiting for business or leisure, you'll find the perfect place that fits your budget and travel needs. Book your ideal Fire Island Pines accommodation today!

We found 14 Accommodations in Fire Island Pines and the surrounding area (within 40 miles)

Cleggs Hotel in Ocean Beach, USA

Cleggs Hotel

Hotel in Ocean Beach near Fire Island Pines, Florida , 478 Bayberry Walk
Located in Ocean Beach and with Ocean Beach reachable within a 8-minute walk, Cleggs Hotel has concierge services, allergy-free rooms, free bikes, fre...
  • Allergy-free room

Very good 46 Reviews 8.4

from $326.81 Show details »

195 Wilmot Road in Ocean Beach, USA

195 Wilmot Road

Holiday home in Ocean Beach near Fire Island Pines, Florida
195 Wilmot Road offers accommodations in Ocean Beach, 20 miles from Nikon Theater and 20 miles from Jones Beach.

Good 1 Reviews 7.0

from $379.88 Show details »

The Madison Fire Island Pines in Fire Island Pines, USA

The Madison Fire Island Pines

Guesthouse in Fire Island Pines, Florida , 22 Atlantic Walk
The Madison Fire Island Pines in Fire Island Pines provides adults-only accommodations with an outdoor swimming pool and a terrace.
  • Pets allowed
  • Outdoor pool
  • Swimming pool
  • Swimming Pool

Exceptional 15 Reviews 9.5

from $290.04 Show details »

The Surfcomber Condos in Ocean Bay Park, USA

The Surfcomber Condos

Apartment in Ocean Bay Park near Fire Island Pines, Florida
The Surfcomber Condos offers accommodations in Ocean Bay Park, a 4-minute walk from Ocean Beach and 20 miles from Nikon Theater.
  • Pets allowed

Exceptional 2 Reviews 9.5

from $257.45 Show details »

Seaside Escape on Huron in Ocean Beach, USA

Seaside Escape on Huron

Holiday home in Ocean Beach near Fire Island Pines, Florida
Seaside Escape on Huron offers accommodations in Ocean Beach, 20 miles from Jones Beach and 14 miles from Bergen Point County Golf Course.

no reviews

from $1.037.80 Show details »

Surfside Retreat On Champlain Street in Ocean Bay Park, USA

Surfside Retreat On Champlain Street

Apartment in Ocean Bay Park near Fire Island Pines, Florida
Surfside Retreat On Champlain Street offers accommodations in Ocean Bay Park, 20 miles from Nikon Theater and 20 miles from Jones Beach.
  • Pets allowed

Fabulous 5 Reviews 8.6

from $435.74 Show details »

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat in Ocean Bay Park, USA

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

Holiday home in Ocean Bay Park near Fire Island Pines, Florida
Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat offers accommodations in Ocean Bay Park, 20 miles from Jones Beach and 14 miles from Bergen Point County Golf Course.
  • Pets allowed

Exceptional 2 Reviews 9.5

from $414.97 Show details »

Pura Vida in Ocean Bay Park, USA

Pura Vida

Holiday home in Ocean Bay Park near Fire Island Pines, Florida
Pura Vida offers accommodations in Ocean Bay Park, 20 miles from Nikon Theater and 20 miles from Jones Beach.
  • Pets allowed

Good 3 Reviews 7.0

from $395.22 Show details »

Salty Dayz in Ocean Beach, USA

Salty Dayz

Holiday home in Ocean Beach near Fire Island Pines, Florida
Salty Dayz is located in Ocean Beach, just 15 miles from Neguntatogue Park and 16 miles from Green Park.
  • Pets allowed

Exceptional 1 Reviews 10.0

from $87.00 Show details »

Sea La Vie in Ocean Beach, USA

Sea La Vie

Holiday home in Ocean Beach near Fire Island Pines, Florida
Sea La Vie offers accommodations in Ocean Beach, 20 miles from Jones Beach and 14 miles from Bergen Point County Golf Course.
  • Pets allowed

Pleasant 9 Reviews 6.4

from $460.23 Show details »

Erie Street Retreat in Ocean Bay Park, USA

Erie Street Retreat

Holiday home in Ocean Bay Park near Fire Island Pines, Florida
Erie Street Retreat offers accommodations in Ocean Bay Park, a few steps from Ocean Beach and 20 miles from Nikon Theater.

no reviews

from $56.00 Show details »

Fire Island Pines Rooms in Fire Island Pines, USA

Fire Island Pines Rooms

Homestay in Fire Island Pines, Florida , 488 Tarpon Walk
Fire Island Pines Rooms features free Wifi and rooms with air conditioning in Fire Island Pines.
  • Pets allowed
  • Outdoor pool
  • Swimming Pool

Exceptional 54 Reviews 9.5

from $164.34 Show details »

The Surfcomber Multi-Residence Home in Ocean Bay Park, USA

The Surfcomber Multi-Residence Home

Apartment in Ocean Bay Park near Fire Island Pines, Florida
The Surfcomber Multi-Residence Home is located in Ocean Bay Park, just 20 miles from Nikon Theater and 20 miles from Jones Beach.
  • Parking
  • Pets allowed

no reviews

from $1.087.89 Show details »

Cherry Grove Enchantment in Cherry Grove, USA

Cherry Grove Enchantment

Holiday home in Cherry Grove near Fire Island Pines, Florida
This beachfront property offers access to a patio and free Wifi.

no reviews

from $3.064.89 Show details »

Number of Accommodations in Fire Island Pines 14
Number of guest ratings 69
Average price per night $293.00
Lowest price per night $34,28
Highest price per night $3.064,89

Top 10 Most Popular Accommodations in Fire Island Pines

Explore the Most Popular Accommodations in Fire Island Pines – Ranked by Average Guest Ratings.

Top 10 Cheapest Accommodations in Fire Island Pines

Discover the Cheapest Accommodations in Fire Island Pines – Ranked by Lowest Nightly Rates.

Top 10 Most Booked Accommodations in Fire Island Pines

Check out the Most Booked Accommodations in Fire Island Pines – Based on Guest Popularity.

Discover Fire Island Pines – Your Guide to the Best Places to Stay

Planning a trip to Fire Island Pines? Choosing the right place to stay is one of the most important parts of making your visit memorable. Whether you are looking for a luxury hotel, a cozy guesthouse, a modern apartment, or a family-friendly vacation rental, Fire Island Pines offers a wide range of lodging options to suit every travel style and budget.

When deciding where to stay in Fire Island Pines, consider key factors like location, amenities, reviews, and proximity to attractions or public transport. Do you prefer being in the heart of the city close to restaurants, shops, and nightlife? Or do you want a quiet neighborhood with a more local feel? With so many types of accommodations in Fire Island Pines, from boutique hotels to spacious homes, you are sure to find something that fits your needs.

Tips for Finding the Perfect Stay in Fire Island Pines

To find the perfect place to stay in Fire Island Pines, consider your budget, preferred location, and the amenities you need. Do you want to stay in a hotel or a vacation rental or do your prefer an apartment or house with more space, privacy, and the opportunity to live like a local? Do you need access to a kitchen, laundry facilities, or a gym? Research online reviews and ratings to get an idea of what past guests have experienced. Also, consider the type of trip you're taking. If you're traveling with family, you may need a larger space or a kid-friendly environment. If you're on a romantic getaway, you may want a more intimate setting.

Accommodation data and pictures provided by Booking.com